Compare the structural differences between the two terms without assuming that one term is universally better or that a generic website can make the choice for you.
Already received a renewal offer from your lender?
Check the rate against current Canadian mortgage benchmarks before you sign. FairRate is paid by you, not by lenders, and does not sell your information to brokers.
Most borrowers compare only after they have already signed. Free check first; paid report options after the check: Rate Fairness Report CA$24 · Full Renewal Decision Report CA$49. No broker calls. No data sold.
A 3-year fixed term and a 5-year fixed term create different maturity dates and different lengths of fixed-rate commitment. Neither is automatically better for every borrower. The decision can depend on the actual written rates, scheduled payments, remaining amortization, penalty wording, prepayment privileges, portability, fees, conditions, expected time horizon, and other circumstances that a generic page cannot fully assess.
FairRate does not recommend a term based on a borrower profile, rate forecast, or a generic rule such as “choose three years if you expect rates to fall” or “choose five years if you want stability.”
| Question | 3-year fixed | 5-year fixed |
|---|---|---|
| When does the term mature? | Earlier than a 5-year term started at the same time. | Later than a 3-year term started at the same time. |
| How long is the quoted rate fixed? | For the 3-year term, subject to the written mortgage contract. | For the 5-year term, subject to the written mortgage contract. |
| When is the next renewal decision? | Sooner, assuming the mortgage remains outstanding. | Later, assuming the mortgage remains outstanding. |
| What should be compared? | Written rate, payment assumptions, penalty wording, prepayment privileges, portability, fees, and conditions. | Written rate, payment assumptions, penalty wording, prepayment privileges, portability, fees, and conditions. |
| Can one term be judged from the other term’s benchmark? | No. Different terms should not be treated as identical products. | No. Different terms should not be treated as identical products. |
A lower quoted percentage does not prove that the associated term is the better product for a particular borrower. Two offers can differ in payment assumptions, penalty calculations, prepayment privileges, portability, fees, promotions, cashback terms, collateral-charge terms, and other restrictions.
Ask for the final material terms in writing and compare like with like. A public advertised rate is not proof that you qualify for it or that a lender will offer it to you.
Future mortgage rates are uncertain. A page should not tell a borrower to choose a shorter term because rates are expected to fall, or a longer term because rates are expected to rise. Forecasts can be wrong, and a term decision includes more than a view on future rates.
This page therefore does not use an unverified current Bank of Canada claim or a market forecast as a personalized term recommendation.
FairRate Canada's benchmark-backed free checker and paid benchmark reports currently support Canadian 5-year fixed renewal offers only. A 3-year fixed offer, variable-rate offer, or other-term offer should not be forced against that reference.
FairRate is not a lender, mortgage broker, mortgage agent, brokerage, underwriter, law firm, or financial advisor. It does not choose a mortgage term for you, issue approvals, guarantee another rate, or promise savings or a particular outcome.
Use the free checker only for the currently supported 5-year fixed comparison. A 3-year offer is outside the benchmark-backed checker scope.
Check a Supported 5-Year Fixed Offer →Review a quoted rate using like-for-like product questions and clear limitations.
Review the written offer, product terms, switching friction, and uncertainty before responding.
See the supported comparison contract, data handling, payment math, verdict rules, and limitations.
There is no universal answer. The terms differ in maturity timing and length of fixed-rate commitment. Review the actual written rates, scheduled payments, remaining amortization, penalty wording, prepayment privileges, portability, fees, conditions, and your own plans before deciding.
A lower quoted rate does not by itself prove that a 5-year term is the better product for a particular borrower. Compare the full written terms, payment assumptions, penalty wording, portability, prepayment privileges, fees, conditions, and expected time horizon.
You can ask what renewal options are available and request the material terms in writing. FairRate does not promise that a lender offers every term or that another option will be priced better.
No. FairRate Canada’s benchmark-backed free checker and paid benchmark reports currently support Canadian 5-year fixed renewal offers only. A 3-year offer should not be forced against that reference.
Important limitation: FairRate Canada is an independent consumer-paid educational comparison and reporting product — not a lender, mortgage broker, mortgage agent, law firm, financial advisor, or mortgage underwriter. FairRate does not arrange mortgages, take applications, approve credit, or sell mortgage inquiries to lenders or brokers. The current benchmark-backed checker and paid benchmark reports support 5-year fixed renewal offers only and use fresh public 5-year fixed comparison context when a usable source is available. Broader Bank of Canada data may be used for contextual purposes. Results are not a lender quote, approval, qualification result, personalized advice, or guarantee of a lower rate or savings. Verify current rates, eligibility, fees, penalties, product terms, and switching costs with the relevant lender and, where appropriate, a licensed mortgage professional or other qualified advisor.